Butternut Squash Ravioli in a Maple-Cream Sauce

I am sometimes guilty of getting a bit carried away with doing things in the most time-consuming fashion.

I’d appreciate it, family, if you would stop laughing now. Thank you.

It’s just that I enjoy making things myself – whether it be a gift, artwork, a note card, or a meal – and so I often strive for the end result in equal parts for the end itself and as a means to execute its components. I find the making gratifying, which keeps it from feeling tedious. This meal is one such effort, and so I will walk you through the protracted instructions for constructing the dish, less the make-your-own-ricotta step, which was truly unnecessary as Narragansett Creamery makes a perfectly fluffy and sweet version that is readily available nearby my house. I’m sure there’s a good cheesemaker making fresh ricotta near you as well, and so you, too, can forget you even heard of making your own ricotta, which requires you to stand over the stove for one hour while the lemon juice slowly works with the heat to create what seems like infinitesimal curds out of the half-gallon of whole milk. Yes, we will skip that step entirely, and when you are done reading through the instructions, you will realize that you can just as easily purchase butternut squash or pumpkin ravioli, or, if you want to go with that semi-homemade trend, you could purchase won ton wrappers and already pureed butternut squash and still experience the joy of assembling your own ravioli. I, however, did it this way:

Butternut Squash Ravioli in a Maple-Cream Sauce

Ingredients

    For the pasta:
  • 3 to 3 1/2 cups Italian "00" flour (a specialty flour for pasta, but if you can't find it, go ahead and substitute all-purpose flour)
  • 6-7 large eggs
  • 1 teaspoon salt
  • 1 tablespoon olive oil
  • For the squash filling:
  • 2 pounds squash, cubed and roasted - please see the butternut squash lasagna post if you aren't certain of the technique for cubing and roasting - and then mashed. If purchasing, you want approximately 2 cups of pureed or mashed butternut squash.
  • 1/2 cup fresh ricotta, preferably not made in your own home
  • 1/3 cup grated Pecorino Romano or Parmigiano-Reggiano cheese
  • 1 tablespoon thyme
  • pepper to taste
  • For the sauce:
  • 4 tablespoons butter
  • 1 large shallot, diced
  • 2 cups light cream
  • 2 tablespoons maple syrup
  • 1 teaspoon thyme
  • salt and pepper
  • For garnish:
  • 1 slice of bacon per person being served, cooked to desired crispness

Instructions

  1. In a mixing bowl, combine 3 cups of the flour, oil, salt, and five eggs. Mix to combine. If the dough is not coming together, add another egg. If it is still not coming together, add another. Then, if the dough is too sticky, add additional flour by the tablespoon until you have a cohesive dough that does not adhere to your fingers each time you touch it. Knead the dough, either by machine or by hand, until it is silken and smooth. Form it into a ball, wrap it in plastic wrap, and place it in the refrigerator to rest for 30 minutes, allowing its strands of glutens to relax. You will have around two pounds of pasta.
  2. While the glutens are in a state of repose, mix the mashed roasted butternut squash, ricotta, grated cheese, and thyme in a medium mixing bowl. Pepper to taste. Salt if you so desire, but I skipped this because the overall salt can be adjusted - in my opinion - in the saucing phase.
  3. Once the pasta dough has sufficiently rested, roll it out into long sheets. I use a pasta-roller attachment on my stand mixer for this. I roll it out twice on the first setting, twice on the second, twice on the third, and twice on the fourth. The resulting thickness is what I consider ideal for lasagna noodles and ravioli.
  4. There are many ways to form ravioli, and I have been making a valiant attempt to try them all. There is the machine-way, which involves another attachment for the stand mixer, and this is quick, provides you with small, uniform ravioli, but wastes a lot of pasta in the process. You can also use ravioli cutters and stamp out the shapes before filling them, resulting in you creating your own won ton wrappers, but this also results in much waste of the pasta. The easiest and least-wasteful way I have found is to roll out the sheets, place them on a well-floured surface - pasta dough is always wanting to stick to itself or the counter if allowed - and create a half-way mark on the short end of the dough as your guide. Place mounds of filling - approximately 1 tablespoon each - an inch or so apart from one another all on the same side of the dividing line. So you have a row of filling mounds, and a row that is naked. Take some warm water in a small bowl, dip your finger in it, and moisten the edge of the dough all around the perimeter. Next, make a line in the same fashion down the length of your dough on your imaginary dividing line, making it real. Then draw a water line between each mound all the way across the dough, such that the line is equidistant from the mound on either side. Gently fold the naked side of the dough up over the mounds, being careful to push out all of the air prior to sealing. This may take a little bit of practice, and you may wind up with an air bubble or two, but neither lack of practice nor air bubbles will ruin the dish. If you have a pasta crimping tool, roll it across the edges to crimp them together and be sure the ravioli are sealed. If not, use the tines of a fork to crimp all around the edge of each ravioli.
  5. If you are using won ton wrappers, the idea is the same, only the wrappers are already ravioli shaped for your ravioli-constructing convenience. Put a mound of filling in the middle of the square, moisten the edges of the wrapper, then moisten the edges of a naked wrapper, and press the moistened edges of each together to seal, also being careful to push out all of the air.
  6. If using neither of these techniques, get thee to a nearby Italian market and purchase some butternut squash ravioli.
  7. With this amount of pasta, which for me was slightly over two pounds, I had 30 ravioli, plus 6 ounces of fettuccine from the remainder of the dough, so using that as a guide, one and a half pounds of pasta dough should yield you enough to make 5 servings of ravioli. They're filling, remember, and the cream sauce is fairly light, but it is still cream sauce, so 6 ravioli per person is more than ample.
  8. In a large sauce pot, bring salted water to boil. At the same time, if using bacon, cook it to your desired crispness.
  9. Just before the pasta water is at a boil, melt the butter in a large saute pan over medium heat. Add the shallot, and cook until translucent, approximately 2 minutes. Add the cream, and allow to simmer for one minute to meld flavors. Add the maple syrup, stirring to combine, then add thyme, salt and pepper to taste, and cook sauce over medium heat, stirring occasionally until ravioli are done. Even fresh, the ravioli will take approximately 7-10 minutes to cook through. The ravioli should be entirely pasta-colored when fully cooked. If they have butternut squash color coming through in the filling area, they aren't quite done. Add the cooked ravioli to the saute pan and allow to simmer in the sauce for a minute or two, spooning sauce over top to coat.
  10. Transfer to serving plates, garnish with salt, pepper, and bacon, and serve them forth. As you may have noticed, this is a very quick recipe if you make it with purchased ravioli, so this could be a weeknight dinner if you go that route, or it could be a lazy winter Sunday meal if you want to make your own pasta and take on all of the making tasks yourself. The sauce comes together in 10 minutes, and would also be good with pork or roasted chicken, so don't miss the opportunity to use it elsewhere. That's part of the fun, after all.
  11. If you have leftover ravioli, you can place them on a rimmed baking sheet lined with parchment paper and place in the freezer for 2-3 hours, or until frozen through. Then, transfer them to a freezer storage bag and use them within a month or so.
https://tinyfarmhouse.com/2008/12/butternut-squash-ravioli-in-a-maple-cream-sauce/

Dinner tonight: Ribollita, which is a Tuscan vegetable soup and an important dish in cucina povera, which translates roughly as “the poor-person’s kitchen” and which is peasant cuisine. The soup is comprised of beans, celery, carrots, onion, garlic, leeks, and tomato, and the broth is made as it cooks, so it is only water that is added to create the broth. Estimated cost for two: $3.04. The beans were purchased at the Providence Winter Farmers Market, which is in the most amazing renovated mill building, so even if you don’t need bread, cheese, grass-fed beef or pork, shellfish, apples, other veggies, or locally-grown beans, you should still check it out. In any event, the beans were $1.25. The celery, onion, and two carrots were no more than a dollar. The leeks were $1.75. The garlic was 12-cents if you consider it was less than a quarter of the 50-cent head of garlic. The can of tomatoes was $1.67. I did buy bread because I was all from-scratched out after making the ravioli AND ricotta myself, so we’ll use about a quarter of a loaf that cost $3.39. That’s 85-cents. The bread is toasted, then rubbed with garlic and placed at the bottom of the bowl of soup to make one bad-ass garlicky crouton. The cavolo nero, or dinosaur kale, was $2.49. This results in 6 servings at a cost of $9.13 for a grand total of $1.52 per person. Poor-person’s kitchen, indeed.

16 Comments to Butternut Squash Ravioli in a Maple-Cream Sauce

  1. CJR says:

    I served this last year and it was phenomenal! I have to confess I bought butternut squash Ravioli pre-made, but I made the sauce and my family loved it!!!

  2. Anonymous says:

    Could you tell me how many servings this sauce makes? Thanks!

  3. Amy says:

    Hi CJR,
    No shame in buying the ravs pre-made – as long as you enjoyed it, that’s all that matters!

    Hi Anonymous,
    You’ll be able to serve 4 to 6 people with this amount of sauce. I’d estimate on the lower end (4 people) just to be safe, and then you have a better shot at having leftovers. Always scheming out how to get leftovers, I am!

    Enjoy!

  4. Anonymous says:

    Sauce was Delish!!!! I also cheated and used store bought ravioli but came home after 10hrs of work so homemade pasta wasn’t gonna happen 🙂 The sauce was soooo good that it didn’t matter…

    Thanks for the great ideas!!

  5. That sauce sounds very good indeed. I will give that a shot with my (store bought) butternut squash raviolu.

    (Btw, bought your book some time back, I think it’s a great resource for those of us trying to eat well but on a budget. Please keep up the good work, people like me appreciate it!)

  6. Justin & Sarah says:

    WOW!! I just made this for my family, and it was delicious! What a wonderful recipe! I am super excited about your blog BTW. 🙂

  7. Anonymous says:

    What happens if you use run-of-the-mill pancake syrup instead? The real deal is pricey in the south.

  8. Amy says:

    Hi Abandoned by Wolves, I LOVE your site name – fabulous! Thank you for the kind words, I’ve been terribly remiss, but I am so glad that you’ve enjoyed the book, and I was incredibly flattered by your review. Thank you for stopping in!

    Hi Justin and Sarah, Thank you! I’m so glad that you found your way here!

    Hi Anonymous, maple syrup is a tough one, particularly if you aren’t in maple syrup country. The maple flavored syrups will still work, they’re just not quite as intensely maple-flavored as the real thing, but it’s worth trying it out. I suspect the flavor will be a little more sweet – still, worth a try! If you do make it, please let me know what you think!

    Thank you!
    Amy

  9. Anonymous says:

    I tried it with Hungry Jack pancake syrup and it was great. I can’t compare it to the real maple syrup, but the dish was amazing!

  10. Amy says:

    Hi Anonymous, Yippee! I’m so glad that the dish worked well for you with the substitution! Great news – thank you for sharing!

    Take care,
    Amy

  11. Meghan says:

    I just made these for dinner tonight and they were so good! My kids are enjoying them too. Can't go wrong with anything maple! I only cooked up 9 of them and froze the rest. Had to roll out the dough by hand, which was a lot of work. Maybe I WILL invest in a pasta machine… thanks for sharing!

    • Amy McCoy says:

      Thank you, Meghan! I’m so glad that you liked them AND that your kids did as well! Rolling dough out by hand is a LOT of work! If you haven’t already bought a pasta machine, there’s one on Amazon that’s around $60 that I use for pasta making classes, and I absolutely love it. It’s the Marcato Atlas Pasta Machine. There are less expensive ones available, of course, but this is nice and sturdy, and works really well.

  12. Mel says:

    About 5 years ago I had butternut squash ravioli for the first time while on a long train ride. It was really great(for a train), and I liked it so much I went in a quest to find a recipe. I found yours some time in 2010 and I’ve made it about a dozen times now. I really want to thank you for posting it! It’s a FANTASTIC recipe and it’s one of my favorite meals to make (though I usually have to take a day to make it).

    • Amy McCoy says:

      Mel, thank you so much for the nice comment! I’m so glad that the recipe works well for you (and I hear you about spending a day to make it – ravioli making is a bit of a task!). Your comment really brightened my day – thanks again!

  13. Anonymous says:

    I made this sauce last night and it was good, but it did not thicken up at all. Is it supposed to be the consistancy of soup?

    • Amy McCoy says:

      Hi there! I’m glad that you liked flavor of the sauce. It is a thin sauce, so it won’t have the consistency of an alfredo or bechamel sauce. With a dish that’s filling like ravioli, I tend to try to keep cream sauces on the lighter side (if that can be done!), so there is no thickening agent, like flour or cornstarch. I hope this helps!